Processing math: 100%

Probability of Perfect Leaf Stacking in a Tree

1. Defining Variables

To calculate the probability of 3,000 leaves falling and stacking perfectly one on top of the other, we define the following variables:

$N = 3000$ : Number of leaves on the tree.
$h_i$ : Height of each branch $i$ from which a leaf falls, averaged over all leaves.
$D$ : Drag coefficient of a leaf as it falls.
$m$ : Average mass of a single leaf.
$g$ : Acceleration due to gravity ( $g = 9.8 \, \text{m/s}^2$ ).

2. Conditions for a Perfect Stack

For a perfect stack, each leaf must:

Fall vertically downward.
Land precisely on the same spot as every other leaf.

This scenario requires that each leaf follows the exact same path and velocity profile to reach the ground at the same point.

3. Considering the Probability of a Perfect Fall Path

Assuming that each leaf has a tiny target area $A$ (the surface area of the leaf), and that the probability $P$ of any single leaf falling precisely on the target area is proportional to this area divided by the ground area over which leaves could potentially fall, we can express:

$P_{\text{single}} = \frac{A}{A_{\text{ground}}}$

where $A_{\text{ground}}$ is the effective area beneath the tree within which a leaf could land.

Probability for All Leaves to Stack Perfectly

Since each leaf's fall is independent, the probability that all $N = 3000$ leaves fall in the exact same spot is:

$P_{\text{stack}} = \left( \frac{A}{A_{\text{ground}}} \right)^N$

4. Simplifying with Estimated Values

For a tree, we can approximate $A_{\text{ground}}$ as a circular area around the tree with a radius $R$ that corresponds to the spread of branches. Let's assume a reasonable estimate:

$R = 3 \, \text{m} \Rightarrow A_{\text{ground}} = \pi R^2 = \pi \times (3)^2 \approx 28.27 \, \text{m}^2$ .
$A \approx 0.01 \, \text{m}^2$ : Approximate area of a single leaf.

Substitute these values into $P_{\text{single}}$ :

$P_{\text{single}} = \frac{0.01}{28.27} \approx 3.54 \times 10^{-4}$

Thus, the probability that all 3,000 leaves land in a perfect stack is:

$P_{\text{stack}} = (3.54 \times 10^{-4})^{3000}$

Calculating the Result

This probability is exceedingly small and can be approximated as nearly zero, demonstrating that while theoretically possible, such an outcome is so unlikely as to be effectively impossible in practice.

5. Influence of Height, Drag, and Weight

The factors like height $h_i$ , drag $D$ , and mass $m$ influence each leaf’s fall velocity $v$ , but given the constraints, these do not alter the probability of a perfect stack. Nonetheless, for completeness, the terminal velocity $v_t$ of each leaf can be estimated by balancing gravitational and drag forces:

$v_t = \sqrt{\frac{2 m g}{\rho A D}}$

where $\rho$ is the air density. For all leaves to fall at exactly this speed and in the same trajectory would be exceedingly improbable.

Conclusion

While mathematically possible, the probability of all 3,000 leaves stacking perfectly on top of each other is infinitesimally small, approximately zero in practical terms.